A ralph and jack respectively represent transformational/ servant leadership and autocratic leadership styles b the novel is about the conflict between these approaches to leading and structuring society. Jack had set the whole island on fire so they could smoke out ralph so they could kill him, but the fire that jack has created got them rescued the fire that saved them, was the fire that jack set to smoke out ralph and kill him and that is the fire that saved ralph from getting murdered. Lord of the flies- leadership being civilized isn't always good when one is on their own in the wild or on an island for instance, but in this novel it is important ralph shows that he is civilized enough to handle the situation he is in. Leadership is something that stands out in people in a group, people tend to look to the strongest person to follow however, the strongest person may not be the best choice to follow in lord of the flies by william golding, ralph and jack each have leadership qualities jack is probably the.
Essay on contrasting ralph and jack in lord of the flies 1112 words | 5 pages contrasting ralph and jack in lord of the flies ralph and jack are both powerful and meaningful characters in william golding's novel, lord of the flies ralph is an excellent leader responsible, and stands for all that is good. As a leader, it seems as if ralph is an optimist and jack is hinting on the side of pessimism jack seems to have a different vision of living than ralph does both of the two leaders also both have different goals and mind sets. However, jack is missing that key characteristic that made ralph so appealing: the symbol of power and strength any sense of leadership that jack held was overshadowed by the image of ralph standing confidently with the conch shell in hand. Jack and ralph have a very different style of leading ralph has a democratic leadership and jack is more of a dictator figure then furthermore, there is the difference of believes, jack believes that the main objective on the island is to hunt and ralph believes that it is to be saved.
Jack is jealous of ralph because ralph is elected the preferred leader jack is often caught smirking and he despises the other's attempt at building communities humiliated, power hungry and envious, jack eventually forces a vote and thrives on division. Jack's wild side, was his greatest weapon, shaping him into a leader jack was around ralph's age, but more on the childish side he was tall, thin and bony. If ralph turned back towards the shelters and jack went on, he would be considered a 'coward', and appear a weak leader to the boys, losing control in order to keep support of the boys, ralph went with jack to search the mountain for the 'beastie' in the dark so jack wouldn't appear braver than he. Ralph, tall, with dark hair, twelve year old, establishes himself as the leader of the boys when he blows the conch shell to call the first assembly throughout the story, he struggles to maintain order, forced to compete with jack for respect. Ralph becomes chief by vote and this establishes a conflict between the different leadership qualities offered by jack and ralph jack demonstrates a military mindset, like hitler strict and authoritarian.
The leadership of jack and ralph in lord of the flies the leadership of jack and ralph in lord of the flies throughout the novel lord of the flies, ralph tries his best to create a society based on survival. Ralph suggests that they choose a leader to make decisions for the group jack immediately says he should be the leader because he is already the leader of the choir, and was the head boy at his. Explain ralph's vision of what the group's goals should be and how they should work based on the text and your interpretation of ralph's leadership explain jack's vision of what the group's goals should be and how they should work based on. Ralph's capacity for leadership is evident from the very beginning (he is the only elected leader of the boys) during the crisis caused by the sight of the dead paratrooper on the mountain, ralph is able to proceed with both sense and caution. Both jack and ralph are very good leaders they both rule two groups, and they both are very good at being leaders, almost as if that's what they do ralph is very good and only makes rules when.
Explore how ralph would like the group to function and how jack would like the group to function explain ralph's vision of what the group's goals should be and how they should work based on the text and your interpretation of ralph's leadership. Throughout the first five chapters of lord of the flies,ralph and jack demonstrate their drastically different leadership styles ralph is more democratic, organized, and sympathetic to the boys' needs ralph understands the importance of creating rules, maintaining the signal fire, and building shelters. The leadership of jack and ralph in lord of the flies: essay examples 2248 words | 9 pages the leadership of jack and ralph in lord of the flies throughout the novel lord of the flies, ralph tries his best to create a society based on survival. Ralph, jack and piggy all have different thought patterns and personalities, jack has the strongest personality and is very vindictive which in a leader are promising qualities, however he is very head strng and fails to think before acting.
Summary: ralph is a better leader than jack in william conrad's lord of the flies because of his democratic approach and civil manner unlike jack, he doesn't want a savage society on the island unlike jack, he doesn't want a savage society on the island. Jack was the leader of the choir at the boys' old school and competes with ralph for the position of alpha male on the island jack was described as dark, a creature, and controlling, rather than leading, the choir. Ralph and jack have two very different types of leadership that are at different ends of the spectrum the qualities of ralph and jack are different, jack's beliefs contrast those of ralph , and the styles of leadership that ralph and jack use are as different as night and day. The leadership of jack and ralph in lord of the flies throughout the novel lord of the flies, ralph tries his best to create a society based on survival as time progresses, it is clear that jack's feelings are towards living life and having fun.
In the novel, lord of the flies by william golding, jack, represents the hidden evil while ralph, his rival on the island represents civilization and common sense ralph is an embodiment of democracy and is willing to be a leader but knows that it's important for each of the boys to be able to. Jack is motivated at different times by a desire to be in control and a desire to kill in the beginning, he continually challenges ralph's authority, drawing attention to himself as often as possible. As donald h mcgannon says, leadership is action, not position in the novel the lord of the flies, author william golding shows how one boy, named ralph, takes action from the beginning and is proven to be the best leader on the island in the end even though jack takes control at the end of the. Ralph's clear understanding of people and their needs make him a far superior leader when compared with jack ralph's understanding of the boys need for stability and order through government and rules prompts him to improve the society in which they are living.